Sign in or Create an account

You need to sign in or create an account to use the Face-Off

jaybueller asks...
Should we get rid of Stat?
Yes!!! (Explain)
No!!! (Explain)

Top Rated
yes i think Amare Stodemire should leave the knicks even thoe i am a huge amare fan i think he sould go because resson number 1 carmelo anthony plays better without him number 2 the whole knicks play better without him and stat is hurt and i heard that he has about 75 year old legs and everybody know that right there should be trade
yes because the first 2 games the knicks won by alot and passing the ball what stat cant do
Give Him the Boot, Not because he isn't good, the team chemistry right now without him is amazing... Get some draft picks, or players that dont not need offensive touches...
Never 100% Team seems to play better w/o him. Trade him...
He is not doing good, he's never 100%, and if the outside shots aren't falling we have other guys like Chandler to score down low. We don't need him and he's basically a liability.
He's not reliable, and we are doing fine, if not better without him.
Stat is awesome. Just might not be what's good for the team. He needs to stay healthy. Let s see what happens when he returns. Then the Knicks should know what to do
his knees are horrible and we play much better without him, and also he gets paid way way too much!
Top Rated
I predict stat coming in strong this season, I honestly think he Melo and the rest of the team are going to mesh really well with the likes of Kidd & Felton controlling the ball.
MANY REASON BUT HERE IS ONE -- When that 3 Ball is not going down -- Stat will put on that PAINT-GEAR and force it in!!! When in that zone he talks to the ball - YOU WILL GET IN THERE NOW!!!
We know that Stat is a asset to this team when he is healthy. His knees and contract make it very difficult to move him if they wanted too.
He'll be back.. more fire power. we need him if he can stay healthy. We know he's a deadly player that can get numbers!!!
Hè is my hero
WTF? SERIOUSLY? STAT IS THE HEART OF THE KNICKS! HE PLAYS TEAM BALL, AND IF MELO COULD SHARE WITH HIM LIKE HE IS SHARING WITH THE LESSOR TEAMATES(I.E. NO JEALOUSY OR BALL/FAME GREED)WE WILL BE A SERIOUS FORCE. GO NY GO NY GO!!!!!!!!!!
no because he still can score the ball , and is a very great player
BEAST
Everyone remembers the Stat Felton pick and roll!!
hell no everyone is to fast wit there conclusions hes an 6 time allstar he is to good to do something dumb like that and he will help the team more than u think
Keep Stat...more fire power (in the paint)
No way brother we are a family we need to support each other he was on his way to a great season he got injure unfortunately!.I believe he gives us real championships hopes.which him well n keep him mentally strong. God bless him.nYk allday...
HE CAN'T BE MOVED!!! Regardless of anything. He's going to be a knick period. You want him traded? sorry, not gonna happen. Finances people, Finances.
It's too early to tell. Last year I wanted melo gone because for a while his shooting sucked, and he wasn't a team player. LOOK HOW WRONG WE ALL WOULDVE BEEN IF WE TRADED HIM.